Reviews & Ratings for Amerigo Restaurant

11/11/11

Really good

by ScionDieHard at Citysearch

They have great food at great prices. I really love the crab cake. I'll be back

03/06/11

Why did I miss this place

by ice333 at Citysearch

I have lived in Nashville for over 5 years now. I drove by this place numerous times, but never had gone in. What a huge mistake that was. I ate here for the first time last night for a friends birthday, simply awesome.

I had the crabcake, divine; the lamb ragu, spicy; and the gelato was for dessert, salty melting into sweet. All in all one of the best meals for the money I have ever had in Nashville. I will definitely be stopping in again.

03/05/11

Delicious!

by andre21 at Citysearch

Always my favorite place to dine when I'm in town. The service and food are always great! The wine list is also one of the best values around.

12/24/10

Ugh, what a waste of money!

by exnuyrker at Citysearch

The first time I went I ordered the salmon plank at the recommendation fo the waiter - wow - was it boring, bland and cool to the touch! The salmon seemed to be cooked well, but it was so bland and the side veggies too! Well, I thought I'd give it another try (since I'd purchased two online coupons) and, much to my dismay, the same experience the second time around - boring, bland and not even hot! This place may have been great at one time, but no more! Bland, boring and cold food is what they serve! I will not be back.

10/17/10

Terrible Food

by DavidENashville at Citysearch

Expensive and bad. Food is over-salted and the flavors are one-dimensional and bland. Amerigo's culinary principle?: smother it in cheese and cream and most people won't care!

There's nothing Italian here except the prices.

If you like cafeteria-style "Italian" then perhaps give it a try.

Also worth a try if you want to feel like swallowed rocks for the rest of your evening.

07/06/10

Great Italian for a great price

by nash2010 at Citysearch

I eat at Amerigo whenever I travel to Nashville for business. I have always had a great experience. I typically sit at one of the bar tables so I can look out onto West End and do some people watching.

Recently I've started trying new menu items and haven't been disappointed yet. The Cheese Fritters are outstanding and the Cedar Plank Salmon is delicious. To make it even better, the price is very reasonable. I wish they would just open one in my hometown!

• Pros: Good service, delicious food
• Cons: Don't have one where I live

01/10/10

Has it all.

by Nortonjaybush at Citysearch

My wife and I stopped by on our way home from a Preds game. We had our jerseys on and everything. We were greeted warmly and seated immediately. We received excellent service despite our appearance. The wine list was very reasonably priced and paired perfectly with the menu. There really is no substitute for great Italian wine with great Italian food. We will be back very soon!

• Pros: Great food, wine, and service

06/23/09

Wonderful place to eat!

by Amarie at Citysearch

My friend and I had a good time at Amerigo. I ordered the Cannelloni Al Forno and It was delicious and the Creme Brule Cheesecake was awsome. It was so big that I couldn't eat all of it. Our waiter Stefan was very nice too. I will definitely be back.

• Pros: Great food and service
• Cons: Parking

03/09/09

It's Good and I'm not an Italian Food Fan

by xizor at Citysearch

The food has always been good. The smoked duck and sausage pasta is spicy and delicious. The lighting has always been bad. If you enjoy sqinting to see your date, ignore previous sentence. The prices have always seemed a bit inflated. The aforementioned pasta dish is $13 with no sides, salads, etc. You decide.

• Pros: service, attention to detail
• Cons: lighting is atrocious

10/06/08

Great Italian Food 4 Good Price!

by LDWin at Citysearch

My husband and I went to Amerigo last time we were in Nashville. We found it through this citysearch site. The food was great and the price was very reasonable. We didn't see any country music stars, but I bet some of them frequent this place. We would if we lived in Nashville!