Pie in the Sky Pizza

05/20/2008 Posted by wrice123417

I went there for the first time this weekend and have to say that there is no place around that has such wonderful pizza. We loved that they have a small section dedicated to people wothout children dining with them, it made our experience much more enjoyable. Although it was obvious that they are very kid and family friendly! My husband and I are already anticipating eating the spiral bread again, and what wonderful service we recieved. The young man that waited on us was Andrew...ask for him, wonderful!

Pros: Great service and food

Cons: be prepared to wait, there pizza takes longer than most

04/22/2008 Posted by carolbyrd

OK, I have to say the Pizza is all that, but I can't get a week away from the spiral breadstick. I also love the Scampi Pizza... how different! It has lemons on it. whoa! Still I'm dreaming of more Spiral Bread....what the heck'd they put in it? XXXOOO Carol

Pros: Yes they are Professionals.

Cons: No I don't think they are convicts.

04/22/2008 Posted by tfromers

My Mother and I go to PieInTheSky in Cool Springs every week. It's the only pizza that doesn't give her indigestion. I spoke with a manager who said that the reason there food is so much better is that they have low acid fresh tomatoes. He also said no trans fats and only real olive oil and butter. I never knew that other oils in the products caused indigestion. It's really great to have a pizza place care so much about the food. Since they don't really advertise the food facts, I thought I'd help them get the word out. They also run the best service outfit I've ever seen in the pizza biz. I read a few of the negative comments on this site and I wonder who writes such complete slams? They don't review the food, they just slam it. Kinda sounds like jealous competition... not real food critics. I've eaten at many other pizza places in Nashville that are all about drinking and cheap food...I prefer great food anyday!

Pros: No Heartburn

Cons: I have to drive 12 miles to get there.

04/21/2008 Posted by hdhicks

Not at all worth the money. Pizza is nothing special and the breadsticks were very greasy. Service was not good either. They just weren't organized. There are much better pizza places in Nashville like Mafiaoza's.

03/30/2008 Posted by berniebld

My wife and I had the best experience at Pie In The Sky in Cool Springs last Thursday. The server was really on top of our needs and cleaned our plates up, re-filled our drinks as well as made great suggestions. I know that’s what a server is supposed to do, but we’ve been to another pizza place in the area that struggles with service and now we have a new favorite place. The food was top notch as well. WE LOVE PIE IN THE SKY!

Pros: Service and Food

Cons: None so far

01/30/2008 Posted by NolensvilleMom

I love PieInTheSky. My favorite Pizza is the Alfredo! They have the best people working there. Thanks for being you.

Pros: Everything

Cons: none

10/16/2007 Posted by remmy65

My family and I had gone to Pie in the Sky Pizza last Friday night. The Pizza is good, however not worth over $20 for a two topping, and $9 for a well mixed drink? The place was also very dirty. The waiter was nice, but everyone seemed so stressed out. The kids did enjoy the dough to play with, but the play area is right in the highest traffic area(servers running back and forth) Call me crazy but I feel I shouldnt have to wait over an hour for a pizza. Overall, just a very uncomfortable atmosphere. On the way out the door I asked my waiter if its always like this? His reply, "only when the owner is here." How often that is, I dont know. I do know that I will not be back.

Pros: Good pizza

Cons: Dirty, expensive, wait too long

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful

09/02/2007 Posted by amanda80tn

The service here is HORRIBLE!! It is just the worst. The pizza is ok, but with the abundance of choices here in Mid TN service makes the difference for me. I was just there Friday night and at 9:00 they started cleaning up, as we were leaving more unfortunate people where coming in, I knew they would get horrible service just for walking in the door 2 hours before closing. They always start cleaning up and shutting down a good hour before closing. The waiters and waitresses obviously HATE the children walking back and forth to the dough bar, but whose idea was it to put it between the kitchen and seating?!?!? I think it is the manger (big guy, never smiles) who is leading this horrible service. My family goes there often, and EVERY time we leave (well before closing time), he never says "thanks for coming" or any other courteous comment as we walk out the door. Many times we have sat waiting on a waiter to take our order while they argued over who would take our table (we are good tippers, just have a few children). If you want GREAT pizza and GREAT service do not go here, GO TO MELLOW MUSHROOM !!!

Pros: okay pizza

Cons: HORRIBLE SERVICE, high price, poor management

0 out of 2 people found this review helpful

08/30/2007 Posted by mario2007

Pizzas are too dry (they lack moistness) and sometimes way too thick to be good. There is a good choice of toppings but "Pie in the Sky" is a little bit cheap with them: large pieces of pizza are not covered at all by any topping !!! Try same genre pizzas in place like Pizza Perfect or Papa John's and you won't eat again in "Pie in the Sky".

Pros: Nice Atmosphere, choice of toppings

Cons: Bad pizza, slow service, a little expensive

0 out of 2 people found this review helpful

08/09/2007 Posted by jtemmer

Last Friday I was having a large family get-together and the 35 of us went to eat in Cool Springs. We drove to several restaurants and were practically turned away with up to 2 hour quoted wait times. Finally a hostess at another restaurant suggested Pie In The Sky Pizza. We just moved here and had never heard of this pizzeria. We were seated in 30 minutes and the kids discovered the “dough bar”. It was a huge sucess. I can’t tell you how they saved the evening. The waiter was great and the food was exceptional. I’ve been raving about how good the place is to all of my friends. I went back on Sunday and the place was packed out, but they still sat us promptly and took good care of us, although there were only three of us then. I saw that they won the “best family friendly dining” contest on this site and I have to agree, no other restaurant we found wanted to take on our large group on a Friday night. I think they need to get a big sign though, because we had never seen them hiding on the side of that furniture company. I’d love to give a review of all of the food, but I’ve only had the Pizza. It’s outstanding. I guess I’ll have to eat there a bunch more and write an in-depth review. Anyway, I hope if you’re planning a group outing you’ll try these guys, they’re superb.

Pros: Large Groups Yes, Great Food!

Cons: Need a Big Sign!!!

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful